Published: Tuesday, June 22, 2010 By Mark D. Marotta, Special to The Mercury
HARRISBURG — Seventeen members of the Spring-Ford Area School District community traveled to Harrisburg Monday morning to hear Gov. Ed Rendell, U.S. Sen. Robert Casey and others, including their own school board President Joe Ciresi, speak in favor of increased funding for public education.
“Very rarely do we ever have the chance to be heard at the state level,” Superintendent Marsha Hurda said, as a school bus with parents, school board members, district staff and students prepared to pull out of the parking lot of the Upper Providence Elementary School at about 8:50 a.m.
One of the rally-goers, Diana DiBello, a Limerick Township mother of two children going into eighth and ninth grades, explained that she was attending because she thought “the education of our children is very important, and I think that the funding that the school district gets is critical to continue the programs that’ll keep our children competitive.”
She added she hoped that the governor would understand the impact of the current financial impact on the school districts.
Arriving at the state Capitol building a little less than two hours later, the rally-goers headed to the nearby Pine Street Presbyterian Church, where a table was stacked with signs with messages such as “Support Public Education” and “No more cuts for our kids.”
Held in the Capitol Rotunda at 11:30 a.m., the rally had been organized by the Pennsylvania School Funding Campaign, a coalition of more than 30 groups working together for improvements in the state’s educational funding system.
Ron Cowell, president of The Education Policy and Leadership Center, explained that the campaign supported a $354 million increase in state support for basic education contained in Rendell’s proposed budget for 2010-11.
According to Cowell, Pennsylvania has one of the worst school funding systems in the country. For instance, he said, in 2007, the state was below the national average in terms of the amount of dollars directed to education from kindergarten through 12th grade. Because of its dependence on local revenue sources, Pennsylvania has one of the most unequal school funding systems in the country, Cowell said. He added that many districts were considering budget cuts because of the financial bind they were in.
In his remarks, Ciresi said that in an effort to balance its budget, the Spring-Ford district had eliminated programs in elementary mathematics support and library services, while programs in art and music had also been altered. Among the financial burdens facing the district, he cited a projected increase in contributions to the Pennsylvania School Employees Retirement System, which will grow from $2.3 million in 2010-11 to $9.3 million in 2012-13.
“Because of the ever-increasing costs that are not directly related to the much needed materials, books, and technology, our children will ultimately suffer in the end,” Ciresi said.
Under Rendell’s budget, he added, Spring-Ford would receive an additional $600,000 over what the district had originally anticipated.
Other speakers at the rally expressed similar sentiments. Marian Rucci, a parent from the Upper Darby School District, in Delaware County, said equity in education was the key to future economic success.
“It is essential that the Senate support this budget bill,” she added. Without passage of the budget, Rucci said, school funding will be cut, which will affect the quality and equality of education for every student.
Susan Berrier, a parent from the Chambersburg Area School District, in Franklin County, said there had been staffing cuts over the past two years, and library services had been cut at the junior and senior high school levels.
“We anticipate larger class sizes,” she added. Berrier also said building plans had been put on hold, as the district had depleted its fund balance over the past two years.
Kris Newbern, a parent in Carbon County’s Jim Thorpe Area School District and the advocacy chair of the Pennsylvania PTA, said school districts had had to make difficult decisions about cutbacks.
“All these cuts have a direct, negative effect” on children, she added. Newbern said districts and children were relying on the state to come through with adequate funding for education.
Noting that 584,000 people were still out of work in Pennsylvania, Casey said it was important to “make the right decisions now” in order to provide for a better future.
“We’ve got to keep our educators working,” he added. It would not only mean that teachers’ jobs were preserved, but also that children would receive the education they need to succeed in the future.
“School districts have been pounded this year,” Rendell said. For instance, he pointed out that the Daniel Boone School District in Berks County had cut staff and was considering rolling back its full-day kindergarten program, while the Penn Hills district, near Pittsburgh, had furloughed nearly 50 teachers.
“And the beat goes on and on and on,” Rendell said.
He added that taxes on natural gas extractions from the Marcellus Shale formation, as well as on the sale of cigars and smokeless tobacco, and the elimination of a 1 percent discount on timely remittance of sales taxes, as well as a 10-cent per pack tax on cigarettes, would generate almost all the money for the proposed $354 million boost in the basic education subsidy.
“It isn’t hard,” said Rendell.
Spring-Ford board member Bernard Pettit asked if the taxes that Rendell mentioned could be dedicated specifically for education.
“It’s a good idea,” Rendell replied. “There’s no legislative appetite to do that.”
In response to a question from Spring-Ford board Vice President Thomas DiBello about the amount of state education funding allocated to Philadelphia, as opposed to Montgomery County, Rendell said that the funding formula established by the Legislature took factors such as poverty levels and the numbers of children for whom English is a second language into consideration. He added that, under the funding formula, Spring-Ford would receive a 252 percent increase over what it would have received otherwise.
Giving an assessment of the rally afterward, Ciresi said he thought it accomplished something.
“They asked us to come, and we gave our side of the case,” he said.
http://www.pottstownmercury.com/articles/2010/06/22/news/srv0000008612235.txt
Comments
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of pottsmerc.com or The Mercury.
badabing wrote on Jun 22, 2010 9:00 AM: ” Show Dem Da Money!
(It’s “for the children”, you greedy people who want to keep your homes!) “
Report Abuse
foleman wrote on Jun 22, 2010 9:29 AM: ” Can these dolts see that the continued funding of the Public Education system is simply not economically feasible? Spring Ford has a 120 million dollar budget! Guess what, almost all of that money goes to teachers salaries and pensions and it goes up every single year! 105K for a football coach! Why didn’t Ciresi mention that? Soon, for many, your school tax bill will be more than your mortgage, Seniors will have a bill that they simply cannot afford to pay! Teachers unions are bankrupting several states-look at Cal-NY-NJ. Chris Christie cuts 850 million from the bloated education budget in NJ and The teachers unions attached him at every turn. 3.5 Billion dollars for education in Philly for a 55% graduate rate, the single largest waste of money in the State. Tax education credits, vouchers, try anything but the current system, we simply cannot afford it and its going to get worse! “
Report Abuse
Target wrote on Jun 22, 2010 9:54 AM: ” Pure theater. Fast Eddie used the rally to try and get his swollen budget passed but he’s a lame duck. The legislators are in control and they know the NOV elections are not far away. Be careful, legislators.
What brought Casey to this silly rally? Sestak, Specter, and Toomey were smart enough to stay away, right?
I wonder who will hire Rendell when his term is up. Maybe, PSEA. Well no, Obama probably has a job waiting for him in DC. “
Report Abuse
Sportsman wrote on Jun 22, 2010 10:15 AM: ” Once again (Foleman, in this instance), another topic of discussion that includes Spring-Ford School District makes reference to the new football coach. Mr. Brubaker was hired as a teacher and the new football coach, and his salary – unless Spring-Ford and every other school district has changed their hiring process – is based on his education/years teaching.
Mr. Brubaker’s teaching salary is very similar to everyone else’s with his credentials (as in education and years teaching), and his coaching salary is in-line with a lot of head football coaches in this immediate area as well as around the state.
Once again, it sure sounds like a few educators (not at Spring-Ford) envy what he makes. I personally envy his commitment to education. It sure sounds like a head football coach or two (definitely not at Spring-Ford) are envious of his coaching salary, which isn’t high at all for a school the size of Spring-Ford or any other school in the Pioneer Athletic Conference for that matter.
People were all over Spring-Ford administration to get rid of Gary Rhodenbaugh, a true gentleman who was not rehired as the head football coach. The administration gets a very, very, very qualified coach in Mr. Brubaker, and one who seems committed to turning the football program around. Now all some of those people want to whine about is his “combined salary.”
Why don’t you go earn a couple of degrees, put your time in as an assistant for a dozen years in a high-profile and very successful football program, and maybe you can make big money too.
Whine, whine, whine … if the Spring-Ford taxpayers and football experts whines could be measured in yards and points the team would never lose a game. “
Report Abuse
thetruth2316 wrote on Jun 22, 2010 10:56 AM: ” Joe Ciresi and Tom DiBello went to Harrisburg in the morning, then returned the same evening and raised my taxes at the school board meeting. Good job guys after you promised us no tax increase when you were campaigning last year. You laid off teachers then hired them back at same salary. What is this voodoo economics? It would be nice if the Mercury reporter would actually report what happened at the School Board meeting. “
Report Abuse
badabing wrote on Jun 22, 2010 11:18 AM: ” @Target: Senator Mumbles was there because the teacher union says “jump” and Junior asks “how high?”.
Junior gets a boatload of money from them, so he is at their beck and call. “
Report Abuse
harmonyville hill wrote on Jun 22, 2010 11:41 AM: ” ‘No more cuts for our kids’ !!!! The kids in public schools today have it better than anyone who went before them. The teacher’s union is not concerned about cuts for the kids but they don’t want to see any cuts for them. Thankfully Rendell is on his way out after all these years of sending this state in a downward spiral. He’s the worst gov we ever had! “
Report Abuse
Raymond wrote on Jun 22, 2010 12:46 PM: ” The teacher’s union is killing the taxpayer….Remember how the steelworkers unions priced the steelworkers out of jobs. The NEA will price the taxpayers out of their homes and who will be left to pay? Now wait….The Government to the rescue, how about ANOTHER bail-out? Wait another moment, who pays for the bail-outs…that’s right, the taxpayers! November elections are critical…Let’s have a tea party and invite those “for the people!” “
Report Abuse
Fasteddie2 wrote on Jun 22, 2010 2:22 PM: ” Why don’t they have a rally to help senior making $1200 a month on social security who has not had a child in the district in 40 years! against the crooks in the teachers union taking $500 a month from them for nothing! Would fast Eddie attend that one? “
Report Abuse
dibello wrote on Jun 22, 2010 2:26 PM: ” Few points of clarification, I never promised not to raise taxes. I stated I would do what I can to reduce spending which with this budget we reduced spending by over $4 million. The tax increase is directly related to pensions, contracted salary increases, and debt service which is over 1/4 billion. The savings is attributed to reduction of programs, switching to self funded insurance and other cuts. For the past several years the district has seen an average 4% tax increase. I think being able to cut that in half during this recession was a good starting point. As informational most of the increase is for the $9 million we will need to contribute to the pension in 2012/2013.
We went to Harrisburg to fight for our district and try to get additional funds instead of watching it go to other districts. Not sure why some would few that as a bad thing. I agree the system is broken and it needs to change but people can’t even agree where to start.
Teachers filling long term sub position are required when a full time teacher takes a leave of absence. We are pleased that we are able to still utilized teachers furloughed due to program cuts.
The teaching salary for the football coach is solely based, as spelled out in the current contract, on his education, experience and years of service. You can’t complain about a football program and then complain about bringing an experienced educator and football coach into the program.
As far as Gary being the previous coach in my eyes he was a solid educator who cared and continues to care not only about his players but all students he interacts with on a daily bases. Reading these and other comments over the past few weeks have been very enlightening; I wish people would come to the board meetings to discuss. I think it would be beneficial for the district and community at large. If you aren’t able to attend the meetings I would be more than happy to discuss any issue related to the district. Please contact me anytime. “
Report Abuse
badabing wrote on Jun 22, 2010 4:00 PM: ” Fighting for funds to go to your district “instead of watching it go to other districts” is one thing.
But this rally was for Rendell’s budget, and for an addtional $354 million in spending – in a state budget where 42% of the entire budget already goes to education spending.
I guess the Government-Education Complex won’t be happy until they get all of it… “
Report Abuse
Bruce Bailey wrote on Jun 22, 2010 4:09 PM: ” Thanks and congrats to the board members and residents who made the trip. As a Spring-Ford taxpayer and parent of a 2010 SF grad, I’m proud of this district and the job that it does. We’re fortunate to have such dedicated faculty, administrators, staff and board members working to help our kids succeed.
I hate to hear people make the argument that “I haven’t had kids in these schools for XX years.” If you’re a member of the community, they are ALL your kids. “
Report Abuse
bigbarney wrote on Jun 22, 2010 5:07 PM: ” The simple reality is that public sector employees and politicians from both parties – most notably Tom Ridge and Ed Rendell – have painted themselves into a corner. By every study that I have seen from The Bureau of Labor Statistics to The Employee Benefit Research Institute, public sector compensation is out of phase with private sector compensation by about 40%. The root causes have typically been overly generous compensation awards and overly optimistic expectations regarding returns on pension funds.
In Europe, where I have worked, there is competition for the education dollars between public schools and private institutions. The net result is that kids are educated at about half the cost here and they score higher on standardized tests. One of the fringe benefits of competition is that it weeds the poor performers out of the teaching profession.
In the near term, one obvious cost containment option would be to graduate kids in three years of high school versus four by extending school years through the summer. It is quite common to read about athletes matriculating at their universities in what would have been the spring semesters of their senior years. So, it is doable. Compensation levels for district employees would remain constant and teachers could prove that they truly have the kids interests at heart. Unfortunately and despite protests to the contrary, right now it is all about the money. “
Report Abuse
badabing wrote on Jun 22, 2010 5:16 PM: ” They are ALL our kids, but that doesn’t mean they get ALL our money… “
Report Abuse
Fasteddie2 wrote on Jun 22, 2010 6:13 PM: ” Dear Bruce Bailey,
If “they are all our kids” them tell them to get off the x box and get over here and cut my grass!
It’s your liberal gibberish that is wrecking this country. If I decide to have 1 child and you have 10, why should I pay the same in property tax! You decided to have more now pay up!
Your logic is like me expecting you to pay for gas if I drive a truck and you drive a Prius!
The system stinks the teachers our overpaid and the schools are a big waste of money! Kids learn better in a shack in India then they do in your palaces, But then again they don’t play X box there! “
Report Abuse
jimmyboy wrote on Jun 22, 2010 8:00 PM: ” To “Fasteddie2″, I don’t know who you are but you took the words right out of my mouth with your last post. Keep after them with your comments. They are the truth and they don’t like it so they attack you. Great posts. “